Skip to content
Unpacking the Narrative: Layli Long Soldier’s ‘The Indian in the Story’ Summary

Unpacking the Narrative: Layli Long Soldier’s ‘The Indian in the Story’ Summary

Layli Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful commentary on the representation of Native Americans in mainstream American literature. Through a series of vignettes, Long Soldier unpacks the harmful stereotypes and tropes that have been perpetuated in popular culture, and challenges readers to confront their own complicity in perpetuating these narratives. In this article, we will provide a summary of Long Soldier’s poem and explore its significance in the ongoing conversation about Native American representation.

The Poem’s Background

Layli Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful and thought-provoking piece that explores the complexities of Native American identity and the impact of colonialism on indigenous communities. The poem is part of Long Soldier’s collection “Whereas,” which was published in 2017 and was a finalist for the National Book Award.

Long Soldier is a member of the Oglala Lakota Nation and was born and raised on the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota. She is also a graduate of the Institute of American Indian Arts and holds an MFA in Creative Writing from Bard College. Her work often explores themes of identity, language, and history, and she is known for her innovative use of form and structure in her poetry.

“The Indian in the Story” is a particularly powerful example of Long Soldier’s work, as it challenges readers to confront the ways in which Native Americans have been marginalized and silenced throughout history. The poem is structured as a series of questions and answers, with the speaker asking about the role of Native Americans in American history and the ways in which they have been portrayed in popular culture. Through this structure, Long Soldier highlights the ways in which Native Americans have been reduced to stereotypes and caricatures, rather than being recognized as complex and diverse individuals with their own unique cultures and histories.

Overall, “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful and thought-provoking poem that challenges readers to confront the ways in which Native Americans have been marginalized and silenced throughout history. Through her innovative use of form and structure, Long Soldier highlights the importance of recognizing the diversity and complexity of Native American identity, and the impact of colonialism on indigenous communities.

The Poet’s Inspiration

The inspiration for Layli Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” comes from her personal experiences as a Native American woman. In an interview with The Paris Review, she explains that the poem was written in response to a conversation she had with a non-Native friend who was reading a book about Native Americans. The friend asked her if she knew any “real Indians” and Long Soldier realized that her friend’s perception of Native Americans was based on stereotypes perpetuated by popular culture. This realization inspired her to write a poem that challenges these stereotypes and explores the complexities of Native American identity. Through her use of language and form, Long Soldier invites readers to question their own assumptions and biases about Native Americans.

The Poem’s Structure

The structure of Layli Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” is unique and deliberate. The poem is divided into three sections, each with its own distinct style and purpose. The first section is written in a traditional narrative style, telling the story of a Native American man who is forced to assimilate into white culture. The second section is a series of fragmented phrases and images, representing the disjointed nature of the man’s experience. The final section is a series of questions, challenging the reader to consider their own role in perpetuating the erasure of Native American culture. Overall, the structure of the poem mirrors the themes of cultural erasure and the struggle to maintain identity in the face of assimilation.

The Poem’s Themes

The themes of Layli Long Soldier’s “The Indian in the Story” are complex and multifaceted. One of the most prominent themes is the idea of identity and how it is shaped by both personal experiences and societal expectations. The poem explores the ways in which Native Americans are often reduced to stereotypes and caricatures in mainstream media and literature, and how this impacts their sense of self. Additionally, the poem touches on the theme of language and its power to both connect and divide people. Through her use of both English and Lakota, Long Soldier highlights the importance of preserving and honoring indigenous languages and cultures. Finally, the poem grapples with the legacy of colonialism and the ongoing struggle for Native American rights and sovereignty. Overall, “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful and thought-provoking exploration of the complexities of Native American identity and the ongoing struggle for recognition and respect.

The Poem’s Tone

The tone of Layli Long Soldier’s “The Indian in the Story” is one of frustration and anger. The speaker is clearly fed up with the way Native Americans are portrayed in literature and media, and she is determined to set the record straight. This is evident in lines such as “I am not a character in your story” and “I am not a metaphor for your guilt.” The tone is also one of defiance, as the speaker refuses to be silenced or erased. Overall, the poem’s tone is powerful and unapologetic, reflecting the speaker’s determination to challenge the dominant narrative and assert her own voice.

The Poem’s Language and Imagery

Layli Long Soldier’s “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful poem that uses language and imagery to convey the complex emotions and experiences of Native Americans. The poem is written in a conversational style, with the speaker addressing the reader directly and using everyday language to describe the events and emotions she is experiencing. This conversational tone helps to create a sense of intimacy and immediacy, drawing the reader into the poem and making them feel as though they are part of the story.

The imagery in the poem is also incredibly powerful, with the speaker using vivid descriptions to bring the events to life. For example, when describing the way that Native Americans are often portrayed in popular culture, the speaker uses the image of a “plastic Indian” to convey the sense of artificiality and superficiality that often accompanies these portrayals. Similarly, when describing the experience of being a Native American in a predominantly white society, the speaker uses the image of a “fish out of water” to convey the sense of dislocation and alienation that many Native Americans feel.

Overall, the language and imagery in “The Indian in the Story” are essential to the poem’s impact and effectiveness. By using everyday language and vivid imagery, the speaker is able to convey the complex emotions and experiences of Native Americans in a way that is both accessible and deeply moving.

The Poem’s Historical Context

Layli Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful commentary on the historical context of Native American experiences in the United States. The poem is set against the backdrop of the Indian Removal Act of 1830, which forced thousands of Native Americans to leave their ancestral lands and relocate to reservations in the West.

Long Soldier’s poem speaks to the ongoing legacy of this history, as she explores the ways in which Native Americans are still marginalized and silenced in contemporary American society. By drawing attention to the ways in which Native Americans are often reduced to stereotypes and caricatures in popular culture, Long Soldier highlights the ongoing struggle for recognition and representation that Native Americans face.

Overall, “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful reminder of the importance of understanding the historical context of Native American experiences in the United States. By grappling with the legacy of the Indian Removal Act and its ongoing impact on Native American communities, Long Soldier’s poem offers a powerful critique of the ways in which Native Americans are still marginalized and silenced in contemporary American society.

The Poem’s Commentary on Colonialism

Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful commentary on the legacy of colonialism in America. The poem explores the ways in which Native Americans have been silenced and erased from history, and the impact that this erasure has had on their communities. Through her use of language and imagery, Long Soldier highlights the ways in which colonialism has shaped the narrative of American history, and the ongoing struggle for Native American voices to be heard. The poem is a powerful reminder of the importance of acknowledging and confronting the legacy of colonialism, and the ongoing struggle for justice and equality for all people.

The Poem’s Commentary on Identity

In “The Indian in the Story,” Layli Long Soldier explores the complexities of identity and the impact of language on one’s sense of self. The poem’s commentary on identity is particularly poignant as it delves into the experiences of Native Americans and the ways in which their identities have been shaped by the dominant culture’s narratives. Through her use of language and form, Soldier challenges readers to question their own assumptions about identity and to consider the ways in which language can both empower and oppress individuals. Ultimately, “The Indian in the Story” serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of recognizing and honoring the diverse identities that make up our world.

The Poem’s Commentary on Language

In “The Indian in the Story,” Layli Long Soldier explores the power dynamics inherent in language and storytelling. The poem’s commentary on language is particularly striking, as Soldier uses language itself as a tool to subvert dominant narratives and reclaim agency for Indigenous peoples. Throughout the poem, Soldier plays with language in a way that highlights its limitations and exposes the ways in which it can be used to erase or marginalize certain voices. For example, she writes, “I am the Indian in the story. / I am the reader of the story. / I am the writer of the story. / I am the story.” By blurring the lines between these different roles, Soldier challenges the idea that there is a single, authoritative voice that can speak for all Indigenous peoples. Instead, she suggests that each individual has their own story to tell, and that these stories are just as valid and important as any other. Overall, Soldier’s commentary on language is a powerful reminder of the ways in which language can be used to both empower and oppress, and of the importance of reclaiming language as a tool for self-expression and resistance.

The Poem’s Commentary on Cultural Appropriation

In “The Indian in the Story,” Layli Long Soldier offers a poignant commentary on cultural appropriation. The poem explores the ways in which Native American culture has been commodified and appropriated by non-Native individuals and institutions. Soldier’s use of repetition and juxtaposition highlights the stark contrast between the lived experiences of Native Americans and the romanticized, stereotypical portrayals of their culture in mainstream media. Through her powerful words, Soldier challenges readers to confront the harmful effects of cultural appropriation and to recognize the importance of respecting and honoring Native American traditions and heritage.

The Poem’s Commentary on Stereotypes

In “The Indian in the Story,” Layli Long Soldier offers a commentary on the stereotypes that have been perpetuated about Native Americans in literature and media. The poem challenges the idea that Native Americans are one-dimensional characters who exist solely to serve as plot devices or to fulfill a certain narrative trope. Instead, Long Soldier presents a complex and nuanced portrayal of a Native American character who is struggling to navigate the complexities of modern life. By doing so, she highlights the ways in which Native Americans have been marginalized and stereotyped in popular culture, and calls for a more nuanced and respectful representation of their experiences. Through her powerful and evocative language, Long Soldier invites readers to reconsider their assumptions about Native Americans and to recognize the richness and diversity of their cultures and experiences.

The Poem’s Commentary on Erasure

In “The Indian in the Story,” Layli Long Soldier explores the theme of erasure and its impact on Native American identity. The poem’s commentary on erasure is evident in the way it highlights the ways in which Native Americans have been silenced and marginalized throughout history. Through her use of language and imagery, Soldier draws attention to the ways in which Native American stories and experiences have been erased from the dominant narrative. She also challenges readers to consider the ways in which their own perspectives and biases may contribute to this erasure. Ultimately, “The Indian in the Story” serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of acknowledging and honoring the diverse voices and experiences that make up our collective history.

The Poem’s Commentary on Power Dynamics

In “The Indian in the Story,” Layli Long Soldier explores power dynamics between Native Americans and non-Native Americans. The poem’s commentary on these dynamics is complex and nuanced, highlighting the ways in which Native Americans are often marginalized and silenced in mainstream society. Through the use of language and imagery, Soldier exposes the ways in which non-Native Americans have historically used their power to control and oppress Native Americans. At the same time, she also acknowledges the agency and resilience of Native Americans, who have continued to resist and fight for their rights despite centuries of oppression. Overall, “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful commentary on the ongoing struggle for justice and equality for Native Americans in the United States.

The Poem’s Commentary on Resistance

In “The Indian in the Story,” Layli Long Soldier offers a commentary on resistance through her use of language and form. The poem is written in a fragmented style, with lines and phrases that seem to interrupt each other, reflecting the disjointed nature of the story being told. This fragmentation also serves to highlight the resistance of the narrator, who refuses to be silenced or erased by the dominant narrative.

The poem’s commentary on resistance is further emphasized through its use of repetition. The phrase “I am not” is repeated throughout the poem, each time followed by a different descriptor that challenges the stereotypes and assumptions about Native Americans. This repetition serves to assert the narrator’s identity and agency, and to resist the erasure of her culture and history.

Overall, “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful commentary on resistance, both in its form and content. Through her use of language and repetition, Layli Long Soldier challenges the dominant narrative and asserts the importance of Native American voices and perspectives.

The Poem’s Reception and Impact

Layli Long Soldier’s “The Indian in the Story” has received critical acclaim for its powerful message and unique style. The poem has been praised for its ability to shed light on the often-overlooked experiences of Native Americans and their struggles with identity and representation. The poem’s impact has been felt not only in literary circles but also in the broader cultural conversation about race and representation. It has sparked important discussions about the need for more diverse voices in literature and the importance of acknowledging the complex histories and experiences of marginalized communities. Overall, “The Indian in the Story” has made a significant contribution to the ongoing dialogue about race, identity, and representation in contemporary society.

The Poet’s Other Works

In addition to her poetry, Layli Long Soldier has also published essays and critical pieces on Native American literature and culture. One of her most notable works is the essay “Whereas: A Writer’s Response,” which was written in response to the 2010 Congressional resolution apologizing for the United States’ treatment of Native Americans. In the essay, Long Soldier critiques the language and tone of the resolution, arguing that it fails to address the ongoing injustices faced by Native communities. She also explores the power dynamics at play in the act of apology, and the ways in which language can be used to both acknowledge and perpetuate harm. Overall, Long Soldier’s work demonstrates a deep commitment to using language as a tool for resistance and healing, and a willingness to engage with difficult and complex issues in her writing.

The Poem’s Connection to Contemporary Issues

Layli Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful commentary on the erasure of Native American voices and experiences in American history and literature. The poem’s connection to contemporary issues is clear, as the ongoing struggle for Native American rights and representation continues to be a pressing concern in the United States. The poem challenges readers to confront the ways in which Native Americans have been marginalized and silenced, and to recognize the importance of their stories and perspectives. In a time when issues of racial justice and equity are at the forefront of national conversations, “The Indian in the Story” serves as a reminder of the ongoing need for greater understanding and respect for Native American cultures and experiences.

The Poem’s Significance in Native American Literature

Native American literature is a rich and diverse field, encompassing a wide range of genres and styles. One of the most important forms of Native American literature is poetry, which has played a significant role in the cultural and political life of indigenous communities for centuries. Layli Long Soldier’s poem “The Indian in the Story” is a powerful example of this tradition, exploring themes of identity, history, and language in a way that is both deeply personal and politically resonant. As we unpack the narrative of this poem, we can begin to see the ways in which it speaks to the larger significance of Native American literature as a whole, and the ongoing struggle for recognition and justice that lies at the heart of this vibrant literary tradition.